Online safety debate: peer claims kids' VPNs 'expose devices to viruses'

1. VPN
2. VPN Privacy & Security

Online safety debate: peer claims kids' VPNs 'expose devices to viruses' News By Samuel Woodhams published 11 December 2025

Lib Dem peer highlights risks of free VPNs in House of Lords

Comments (0) ()

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

• Lib Dem peer warns of dangers associated with free VPNs
• Minister says government will address "evidence gap"
• Not all free VPNs pose the same risk

A Liberal Democrat peer has claimed children in the UK are turning to free VPN apps that "monetise user data and expose devices to viruses" to dodge age restrictions.

Baroness Benjamin opened a House of Lords debate last week by asking the government how they're working to stop children from using the privacy tools to bypass the Online Safety Act.

In response, Liz Lloyd, a science and technology minister, told peers that the government is working to address the "evidence gap" regarding how many children are using the tools. She added that the government is committed to ensuring any "future interventions are proportionate and evidence-based".

You may like

• Could VPNs be banned? UK government to look "very closely" into their usage following spike after age verification row
• A Deal with the Devil? Free VPNs still widespread across the UK
• "The Michigan bill is a danger for the political discourse" – Proton slams verification laws turning VPNs into a liability

This is the latest in a series of parliamentary discussions that have referenced the technology amid growing frustration that the government's landmark safety legislation is being sidestepped by easily accessible software.

Ofcom is monitoring VPN use in the UK, but there's no indication that a ban is imminent.

What can we learn from the debate?

The use of VPNs to circumvent the Online Safety Act has been a concern since at least 2022. However, there’s now growing appreciation among politicians that the issue can’t be easily fixed.

The Bishop of Norwich, Graham Usher, acknowledged that it is "very hard to police the use of VPNs," while stressing the importance of education in protecting children online.

Meanwhile, Baroness Benjamin asserted that "teenagers actively seek out and share methods to circumvent" the age verification process.

Peers also acknowledged the literacy gap between legislators and the children they are legislating for.

Baroness Thornton noted: "I do not know how many noble Lords here would know how to download a VPN and then choose a country which has no age-verification rules. It is clear that there are teenagers who can do this."

You may like

• Could VPNs be banned? UK government to look "very closely" into their usage following spike after age verification row
• A Deal with the Devil? Free VPNs still widespread across the UK
• "The Michigan bill is a danger for the political discourse" – Proton slams verification laws turning VPNs into a liability

Given this growing awareness of VPNs and their potential to circumvent the Online Safety Act, it’s unsurprising that the government finds itself on the defensive again.

For now, ministers can only point to Ofcom’s ongoing investigations – a stance unlikely to satisfy child safety advocates like the Children's Commissioner for England, who urged for immediate action to close the VPN loophole.

A note on the risks of free VPNs

It’s encouraging to see politicians raising such well-informed perspectives on VPNs.

After reporting on the VPN industry since 2018, I didn’t expect to find myself nodding in agreement with life peers and senior religious figures. But Baroness Benjamin is right: many free VPNs can – and often do – monetise your data and leave you vulnerable to malware.

However, there is a distinction to be made between these dangerous "scam" apps and legitimate free services. If you are going to use a free tool, it’s vital to ensure that it is from a verified provider; our guide to the best free VPNs is a good place to start.

That said, free services will always be limited by data caps and slower speeds. For a fully unrestricted experience that guarantees your privacy and security, we recommend upgrading to a premium service like NordVPN, Surfshark or Proton VPN.

Distinguishing between apps that pose a genuine threat like those Baroness Benjamin warned of and those that work to protect digital privacy will be essential for the government to inform effective legislation.

It’s also vital they keep in mind the ministers’ insights from a separate debate in the House of Lords from the same day. Namely, that “there are legitimate reasons to use VPNs.”

Hopefully, the government takes notice of the knowledgeable contributions from this debate and lives up to its promise that any future legislation will be proportionate and grounded in reality.

Today's best NordVPN, Surfshark and Proton VPN deals+3 MONTHS FREENordVPN 2 Year US$2.99/mthView+3 months freeSurfshark 24 Months US$1.99/mthViewProton VPN 24 Month US$2.49/mthViewWe check over 250 million products every day for the best prices Samuel WoodhamsSocial Links NavigationVPN Managing Editor, TechRadar

Sam is VPN Managing Editor at TechRadar. He has worked in the VPN industry since 2018 and has previously written for CNN, Al Jazeera, WIRED, and Deutsche Welle as a freelance journalist. He focuses on VPNs and digital privacy, cybersecurity and internet freedom.

Before joining TechRadar, Sam carried out research on global digital rights issues at Top10VPN. His research has been cited by the United Nations and UK Parliament, as well as publications such as The Guardian, Washington Post and BBC.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Logout Read more Could VPNs be banned? UK government to look "very closely" into their usage following spike after age verification row    A Deal with the Devil? Free VPNs still widespread across the UK    "The Michigan bill is a danger for the political discourse" – Proton slams verification laws turning VPNs into a liability    Australia expects platforms to "stop under-16s from using VPNs" to evade social media ban    The best age verification VPNs in 2025 – avoid handing over your data insecurely when browsing online    How to choose an age verification VPN    Latest in VPN Privacy & Security Mullvad retires OpenVPN support on desktop, pushing all users to WireGuard    Switzerland will revise proposed law change after backlash from tech industry    Taiwan blocks RedNote app, sparking VPN surge    Bluesky enforces age checks to comply with Australia's under-16s social media ban – and reverses Mississippi's block    UK has "no plans" to replicate Australia's social media ban (yet)    Under-16s social media ban lands in Australia    Latest in News ICO levies £1.2 million fine against LastPass — data breach compromised info on 1.6 million users    How to watch Celtic vs AS Roma: Europa League 2025/26 free stream, TV channels, kick-off time    ‘They gave us the iPhone camera’: F1 producer Jerry Bruckheimer on Apple’s ‘phenomenal’ involvement in the movie’s production    The Galaxy Z TriFold has a neat PC trick that could justify its price tag    Nvidia develops new software to help track chips following smuggling discovery    Microsoft has just made Phone Link even better with Android apps    LATEST ARTICLES

1. 1Switzerland will revise proposed law change after backlash from tech industry
2. 2Disney and OpenAI are set to open the vault to Sora — yet an AI Mickey feels like magic lost
3. 3Nvidia develops new software to help track chips following smuggling discovery
4. 4Goodbye June review: New Netflix movie is a near flawless directorial debut for Kate Winslet — but you’ll cry your eyes out
5. 5Mullvad retires OpenVPN support on desktop, pushing all users to WireGuard